While William McGonagall has been deceased for over a century, Tim Harford has recently revisited the poet's legacy on Revisionist History. Harford admits to being "obsessed with William McGonagall," struggling to reconcile the legendary poor quality of his work with his enduring fame.
Harford challenges the traditional narrative that paints the poet as a mere victim of ridicule. On Revisionist History, he posits that William McGonagall might actually be "the most brilliant clown who ever lived," suggesting that the poet was potentially laughing at his audience from behind a deliberate mask of incompetence.
To illustrate the lengths to which William McGonagall would go for his craft, Harford recounts the poet's grueling 1878 expedition. After being duped by a fake letter of patronage from Queen Victoria's secretary, the poet walked 59 miles to Balmoral Castle in hopes of a performance. As Harford notes, "For an unemployed weaver, there was no way to reach Balmoral except to walk."
